Non-Reappointment or Dismissal
This guidance primarily applies to non-tenure-track faculty, including clinical faculty, lecturer faculty, and professors of practice. Some principles may also apply to tenure-track faculty during the probationary period and to research faculty whose appointments have not yet expired.
This page provides an overview of university policy and campus procedures. Because non-reappointment and dismissal decisions involve significant legal and policy considerations, schools should consult the Provost’s Office early in the process. Questions should be directed to ude[dot]ui[at]rhdaca.
Overview
Indiana University distinguishes between non-reappointment and dismissal.
- Non-reappointment occurs when a faculty member completes an existing appointment, and the university decides not to renew that appointment for an additional term.
- Dismissal occurs when a faculty member's employment ends before the expiration of the current appointment period.
The standards, documentation requirements, and procedural protections differ significantly between these two actions.
Importance of Early Documentation
When concerns arise regarding a faculty member's performance, units should address those concerns promptly and consistently.
Appropriate documentation generally includes:
- Clear communication regarding performance expectations;
- Specific examples of performance deficiencies;
- Opportunities for the faculty member to respond;
- Reasonable opportunities for improvement;
- Identification of support structures, if needed;
- Follow-up discussions regarding progress; and
- Explicit communication regarding potential consequences if improvement does not occur.
A successful performance-management process typically includes evidence of four elements:
- Performance concerns were identified.
- The faculty member was informed of those concerns.
- The faculty member was given an opportunity to improve.
- The faculty member was informed of the potential consequences of continued unsatisfactory performance.
Annual reviews should be supplemented by Performance Improvement Plans (PIPs), additional meetings, memoranda, or other written communications when significant concerns exist.
Non-Reappointment
All non-tenure-track faculty appointments have an established end date.
For most faculty, this date is:
• May 31 for 10-month appointments; or
• June 30 for 12-month appointments.
When a faculty member is reappointed, the appointment end date is extended. When a faculty member is not reappointed, the appointment simply concludes at the end of the existing appointment period.
Notice Requirements for Non-Reappointment
Indiana University policy establishes minimum notice periods for non-tenure-track faculty on full-time, year-to-year appointments. These notice requirements are intended to provide faculty with adequate time to prepare for a transition if an appointment will not be renewed.
Under BOT-18: Permanent Separations for Academic Appointees, notice of non-reappointment must be provided in writing according to the faculty member's length of service:
- During the first academic year of service: Notice must be provided no later than February 1 if the appointment expires at the end of that academic year. If the appointment ends during the academic year, notice must be provided at least three months before the termination date.
- During the second academic year of service: Notice must be provided no later than November 15 if the appointment expires at the end of that academic year. If an initial two-year appointment ends during the academic year, notice must be provided at least six months before the termination date.
- After two or more years of service: Notice must be provided at least twelve months before the expiration of the appointment.
Because of these notice requirements, schools review appointment end dates well in advance of their expiration and make reappointment recommendations on a recurring schedule under the direction of the Provost's Office.
Example
Consider a faculty member in their third year whose appointment ends on June 30, 2031. Because the faculty member has more than two years of service, the school must either:
- Recommend reappointment and extend the appointment by one or more years; or
- Provide notice of non-reappointment
by June 30, 2030, at least one year before the appointment expires. The Provost's Office will contact the school in March 2030 to request its appointment decision. The faculty member will receive a notice of the appointment decision from the Provost or Chancellor in May 2030.
A non-reappointment decision does not terminate a current appointment. Rather, it means that the existing appointment will conclude on its established end date after the required notice period has been provided.
Faculty Rights
Faculty members may seek review of non-reappointment decisions through a Faculty Board of Review.
Faculty may also raise concerns through the Office of Civil Rights Compliance if they believe a decision was affected by unlawful discrimination.
For these reasons, documentation should be thorough, factual, and consistent throughout the review process.
Dismissal
Dismissal is the termination of a faculty appointment before the expiration of the current appointment term. Because dismissal interrupts an existing appointment, it is subject to substantially greater procedural protections than non-reappointment. Dismissal of academic appointees is governed by BOT-18: Permanent Separations for Academic Appointees.
Grounds for Dismissal
Under BOT-18, dismissal may occur only for:
• Incompetence;
• Serious personal or professional misconduct;
• Extraordinary financial exigency; or
• Other grounds identified in policies governing specific appointment categories.
Dismissal is not intended as a substitute for routine performance management or annual review processes.
Expedited Dismissal for Serious Misconduct
In most circumstances, a faculty member is entitled to substantial notice before dismissal becomes effective. A shorter dismissal timeline is permitted only when serious personal misconduct:
• Poses an ongoing threat to the safety or security of the university community;
• Involves repeated acts of the same type of misconduct; or
• Results in a felony conviction.
When to Contact the Provost's Office
Schools should contact acadhr@iu.edu as early as possible when:
- Significant performance concerns arise;
- Non-reappointment is being considered;
- A faculty member may be subject to dismissal;
- Questions arise regarding notice requirements;
- Documentation expectations are unclear; or
- A situation involves potential misconduct.
Early consultation helps ensure compliance with university policy and supports fair and consistent treatment of faculty.
Reviewed and revised: 7/2026.
